So the old Taoist story goes like this:
There once was a poor farmer from a poor village who owned a horse. One day, his horse ran away. The neighbors stopped by to console him for his loss. The farmer said, “Don’t know. Might be good. Might be bad.”
Some days later the horse returned along with several other horses. The neighbors came by to congratulate the farmer on his good fortune. The farmer said, “Don’t know. Might be good. Might be bad.”
Sometime later the farmer’s son went riding on one of the horses and was thrown and broke his leg. The neighbors came to offer their sympathies for his bad luck. The farmer said, “Don’t know. Might be good. Might be bad.”
A year later a war broke out, but the son was exempt from serving because of his lame leg. Once again the neighbors came over to exclaim over the farmer’s luck. The farmer said, “Don’t know. Might be good. Might be bad.”
…And so it goes.
I’ve been thinking about this ancient story a lot since the election. There are so many lessons to unpack from this old tale—themes of impermanence, the limitations of our short perspectives, the idea of luck and misfortune/winning and losing. But mostly I have been mulling over this story because as much as I want to celebrate and rejoice that my fellow Americans have finally come to their senses, have seen the light and have turned away from the darkness, I’m hesitant. I don’t know. Might be good. Might be bad.
Which is an interesting place to sit for sure.
Having said that, when I woke up the Wednesday morning after the elections to a text from Matt (he had spent the week in Texas) that the House and Senate had both flipped, I cried.
I hadn’t realized until then how heavy the burden of ugliness and hatred and meanness had been. Maybe you felt the same way.
Here’s what I do know: change is in the air. The leaves are showing off their brilliant fall colors. We’ve changed our clocks. Halloween is behind us (and maybe some of the general scariness?). I feel very grateful. This might be good. It might be bad, but maybe—just maybe—it might be a bit easier for a while. A bit lighter. A bit kinder. Here’s hoping.
But as the late Wendell Berry reminds us, “The deal we are being offered appears to be that we can change the world without changing ourselves.” Or in Gandhi’s words: we must be the change. Both short-term and long-term, there is work to be done and ways we must show up for each other. It’s not just about gas prices; we must stop consuming more than our share of the world’s resources. We are going to have to look at our habits of isolation—individually and globally—and rethink our biases and suspicions about our neighbors. We might need to shut down our devices and start talking to each other in real life. There are no easy solutions, no AI shortcuts. Literally and metaphorically, there are practice boxes to fill. Might be good. Might be bad. But we must be the change in the world.
The November 2026 Playlist of Practices:
Writing (from Find a Star November 2024):
Recently a friend and I were talking about the state of the world. “It’s hard to know what to think,” Jeff said. “There’s a lot of noise out there.”
That’s just it, isn’t it? There’s a lot of noise out there.
At this point, we should know better than to listen to the noise. But it’s so, well, noisy. Loud. In our faces. It is hard to think.
“It’s time to get off our phones and start picking up trash,” another friend said to me last week. I don’t think that’s just a metaphor. I think we need to start picking up trash. Quite literally.
…Last week our “Making Lying Wrong Again” sign was stolen. I had been out hiking that morning and came home to discover it was gone. I wasn’t particularly surprised. In fact, I was rather surprised that the sign had lasted as long as it did. The next day, I was teaching when my neighbor showed up at my front door holding our sign. “I thought it had been stolen!” I said when I saw him.
“It was stolen,” he replied and proceeded to tell me an unbelievable tale. According to my neighbor, the previous morning his wife saw a couple of guys walk by and take the sign. She didn’t want to confront them, so let it go. A few hours later, she saw another guy walk past in the opposite direction carrying the sign. A few hours later, another person walked by the other way with the sign. We later learned that somehow the sign kept landing on the doorsteps of neighbors up and down the street who would then try to return it to the right house. “It belongs down in the other block,” one person apparently said, “you know, where that piano teacher is.”
“Clearly, we all want you to have this sign back in your yard,” my neighbor said handing it to me. It was almost—almost!—enough to give me hope again.
I am reminded of something a friend told me about attending a yoga class on the evening of 9/11. The teacher approached the class as if nothing had happened that day, just led the group through one pose after another. At the time, my friend was bothered by this seemingly indifference to the tragedy of that morning. But later as she thought about it, she realized that maybe this response was intentional and thoughtful, that as people of practice maybe it is our job to show up and keep practicing. We return to the yoga mat, the piano bench, the meditation cushion. The world will always pivot and spin and shift around us; we keep practicing.
I have been thinking about this a lot as I brace myself for Tuesday. “So when at times the mob is swayed/To carry praise or blame too far,” goes a favorite Robert Frost poem. “We may choose something like a star/To stay our minds on and be staid.”
It might, I think, be a good idea to get some stars in order. Regardless of what happens this week, there will be leaves to rake and trash to pick up, wood to chop and floors to sweep. Maybe we should plan to plant pansies. Get vaccinated. Teach a kid to read, or at the very least, to tie their shoes. Learn to say “hello” in three other languages, or memorize a beloved poem. Eat extra vegetables and do five sun salutations. Swim laps and go for a walk. Turn off our phones. There will be so much noise. So. Much. Noise. Maybe it is our sacred and holy work to seek out some silence somewhere and breathe.
…Friends, there always will be trash to pick up. Find a star.
Gardening:
After the wettest October in recent history, New Mexico is green, green, green. Or said another way: We are covered in weeds.
There are weeds everywhere. The alleys are sprouting mustard weeds. My neighbor is cultivating a goat head farm. Properties that in August were all rock are now all weed.
Usually the gardening tasks are done by November and the inside tasks of cooking and baking and decorating have begun. Not this year. Everyone is outside weeding.
Just this morning I came back from the Zen Center and decided to put in my 10 minutes of daily weeding before I went inside and put on the tea kettle. I found myself thinking about that old gardening saying—Right Plant, Right Place—and how that might be applied to the structure of one’s day. There are so many considerations: sunshine, food and water needs, energy levels, work obligations, the other people/the other plants we share our space with, our own ever-changing moods and whims. There is a perfect spot for every green plant, an ideal job that fits every hour. Right plant, right place.
And it is also true that we living creatures are often more flexible than we think. There’s room to play inside our rigid routines: My huge euphorbia works equally well in the east-facing sunroom window or in Matt’s west-facing study. I can swim at 6am or, sometimes after a late night, noon is better. I love to sit down at the piano mid-morning, but when I find myself having to practice in the evenings, I’m often amazed at how inspired it feels. I notice different things, apply novel practice strategies to old problems, hear the music in a fresh way. Right plant, right place? Yes, absolutely. And maybe not.
Practicing/Rehearsing/Listening/Teaching:
Maybe it is all a variation on a theme.
Last weekend I played a program of theme and variations with my favorite violinist and dear friend, Ruxandra. We played Themes and Variations by Messiaen, by Mozart, by Haydn, by Gershwin, by Barber. I loved this program. I could play themes and variations all day long. I’m fascinated by what a skilled composer might do with a tune. Maybe major. Maybe minor. Maybe upside down or inside out. Maybe half-time or double-time or covered in ornaments and bling.
Of course, practicing in general is just one theme with endless variations. We practice hands separately, super slo-mo, backwards choo-choo, ghosting. We apply opposite dynamics and articulations, scramble memory spots and sections, start with ColdPlay every day.
And also practice sandwiches*. Lots of sandwiches.
Just ask the kids, who have been getting ready for our Fall Studio Recital. Even before I have their music open and their practice notebook ready, they have things to say. “What I really think is helping me,” they tell me, “are practice sandwiches. We definitely need more practice sandwiches.” “Did Miss Amy give you practice sandwiches too?” I hear them asking each other in studio classes.
Lately it has felt like my life was one big practice sandwich.
There was that theme and variations set of concerts last weekend. In the weeks before that I had two other big programs to prepare. All fall, I have been on a practice treadmill, my day a huge practice sandwich: Yoga. Swim. Read. Desk work. Piano. Teach. Piano. Teach. Weeding. Teach. Piano. Meditation. Teach. Walk. Dinner. Bed. Right plant, right place? Yeah, whatever.
A practice sandwich is not magic. It’s just a work hack. One returns to the task, to the problem spot, to the piece, to the passage repeatedly interspersing other work/practices/tasks in between the trouble. In my own practicing there have been so many troubles—that nasty variation in the Messiaen. The small choral group program that required texts in Russian, Estonian and Ukrainian. That big old piece for the Quintessence concert last month, which was hard on my hands and my brain. So many problems. So many sandwiches.
And then there are the students and their troubles: that one pre-teen who has a perfect back-up piece to play on the recital but is fixated on wanting to play a stretch piece that is just beyond his reach. That wicked spot in that Chopin Nocturne. That repeated memory lapse in the same spot in the Kapustin Sonatina. “I can barely handle my own heavy practice load these days,” I complained to Matt one night after a long day of teaching. “Right now getting 30 kids ready for their recital feels like too many practice sandwiches. I’m dying here.”
Last Saturday, minutes before the final concert of the Movable Sol set, the last variation in the months-long theme of practice sandwiches, the electricity unexpectedly went out in our venue. Movable Sol is a house concert series, and we had a full house of attendees. Dusk was falling quickly, the light was fading. There was no explanation for why the power had suddenly failed.
Our gracious hosts set up camper lanterns around the piano and the concert began. Suddenly, I was grateful for the insane practice requirements of this tricky program. I had practiced so much, worked through so many practice sandwiches in the last month, that the music was nearly memorized. It needed to be, because during the next hour it only got darker.
It was magical, a perfect variation on a theme. Afterwards, someone said to me, “It was like being transported to the time of Mozart and Haydn and what house concerts would have felt like then.” And just as we started the joyous theme of the last piece on the program, the lights went on, as if by our perfect cue. Pure magic.
Friends, the future might be good, might be bad. There will be moments of darkness and light, but we are in the right place at the right time. We must be the change. Keep practicing.
*There are a whole bunch of scientific reasons practice sandwiches work. Read more here.